Third Down and a
War to Go
was a 2007 trade paperback. David
Maraniss of the Washington Post
wrote the foreword.
University of Oregon coach Jerry Frei died in 2001, many of his former Ducks players attending his memorial services were
astounded to learn that he had been a decorated P-38 fighter pilot in World War II. He never brought that up with his players.
But like so many other veterans, he hadn’t talked much about the war with his children, either.
Late in Jerry Frei’s life, his son
– author and journalist Terry Frei – belatedly began asking more questions about the young pilot’s experiences.
As they talked, a frame of reference was the Wisconsin Badgers’ 1942 team picture on Jerry Frei’s den wall. Sophomore
backup guard Jerry Frei, then only 18, was in the fourth row of that 1942 photo, behind All-American end Dave Schreiner and
star halfback Elroy “Crazylegs” Hirsch. The elder Frei spoke of how the players on one of the greatest
college football teams of all time went off to serve their country after their glorious season – and about how not all
of them made it back.
After his father’s death, Terry Frei set out
to learn more about the team and the men in that picture. What he learned left him forever changed.
On December 11, 1941, Schreiner wrote to his parents,
“I’m not going to sit here snug as a bug, playing football, when others are giving their lives for their country.
. . . If everyone tried to stay out of it, what a fine country we’d have!” Schreiner didn’t stay out of
it. Neither did his teammates.
In the final-fling atmosphere common on college campuses as the first year of U.S. involvement
in the war was winding down, the Badgers climbed up the national rankings under the guidance of coach Harry Stuhldreher, the
quarterback of Notre Dame’s famed “Four Horsemen.” Stars and scrubs alike had enlisted in various branches,
were awaiting their callups, and knew that each game brought them closer to military service.
Schreiner and the Badgers’ other co-captain, halfback Mark Hoskins, both came from tiny Lancaster, Wisconsin,
and the long-time buddies and teammates both planned to become pilots. But Schreiner’s color blindness ruled him out
as a pilot, and after he renounced a pre-medicine student deferment, the two-time All-American end became a Marine officer.
As the war raged on, the Badgers sailed through Harm’s
Way, fought in the Battle of the Bulge, pushed the envelope as pilots, and led units in the fierce Pacific island battles.
Through exhaustive research and interviews with the
remaining Badgers, their families, and combat comrades, Terry Frei tells the story of this band of brothers. In particular,
the climactic material about the "Great Escape" prison camp, plus the Battle of Okinawa and the role of several
Badgers in it, has tugged at readers’ hearts.
Readers and reviewers agree: This isn't about one team. It's an
Online Interview with Terry Frei about Third Down and a War to Go
Public radio Interview with Terry Frei about Third Down and a War to Go
Denver Post story that started
it all ... Grateful for the Guard
Barnes and Noble:
Excerpt: Monumental 1942 Ohio State-Wisconsin game
The Death of Dave Schreiner and Other World War II stories
is nice. Truth is better. The '42 Badgers were boys being boys. Good for them. Good for Terry Frei, who chose to write their
story truly in his book, Third Down and a War to Go: The All-American 1942 Wisconsin Badgers.What a powerful piece of work the book is, a telling detail in
the great portrait of America at war, young men and women who saw their duty and did it no matter how much it scared them."
-- Dave Kindred, The Sporting News and
author of Sound and Fury
“Many times you hear athletes called heroes, their deeds
and accomplishments on the field or court are characterized as courageous. After reading Third Down and a War to Go,
I am embarrassed to have ever been thought of as brave or courageous. Enjoy this adventure in history, life, and in courage
and take it from a so-called ‘tough guy’...keep the hanky close by.”
--Dan Fouts, Hall of Fame quarterback and ABC-TV
"...a book that not
only makes you keep reading, but makes you care...The last chapter in Frei's book, 'Lives and Deaths,' details what happened
to everyone from that squad, and by the time you get there, you really want to know about them. It's that kind of book, relatively
modest in intent but rich in fabric and execution."
--Dwight Chapin, San Francisco
"Here’s a book written with love and passion . . . What began as a sports book comes to
resemble something akin to 'Band of Brothers,' by the late Stephen Ambrose (who played for the Badgers more than a decade
later). . . This is an inspiring book, full of fun and pathos and heroism."
--Dave Wood, past vice-president of the National Book Critics Circle and former book review editor of the Minneapolis
"Of all the traits of the World War II generation, perhaps the most impressive some 60 years later is the ability
to make do, no matter the circumstances, and with little ceremony at that. That theme echoes throughout author Terry Frei's
thoroughly researched and ardently objective book, a chronicle of the 1942 Badgers' rapid transition from carefree college
clashes against Notre Dame and Minnesota to battling Nazi Germany and imperial Japan. . . The first half of the book establishes
the principal characters and the 'swell' atmosphere of the day, to borrow some period terminology, while detailing an 8-1-1
season in which the Badgers were deemed mythical national champions by the Helms Foundation. With the war heightening, the
majority of the players were sent overseas to fight on the front lines, and Frei follows them relentlessly in the book's second
half, focusing mainly on (Dave) Schreiner and (Mark) Hoskins. It's a logical choice, given their long friendship, their disparate
assignments and Schreiner's status as an All-American . . . Either half of the book would have stood alone, but together
they do supreme justice to a group all too soon gone, all too easily forgotten."
-- Adam Mertz, The Capital Times, Madison
"With its members serving on all fronts, the 1942 Wisconsin Badgers become
a microcosm of the American war effort, representatives of a remarkable generation of self-sacrificing Americans. . . . Through
Hoskins and Schreiner, the cocaptains of the 1942 team, the author makes his most important point. Frei portrays the young
men who played football at the University of Wisconsin in 1942 and later fought for their country as truly 'All-American'
boys. Having embraced the opportunity to serve his country and risk the ultimate sacrifice, Dave Schreiner -- as both a star
athlete and all-American on the football field as well as a man of impeccable character off it -- was the definitive symbol
of this. Written with the passion of an inspired student, Third Down and a War to Go is fulfilling and powerful.
It adds athletic perspective to our understanding of the 'Greatest Generation' as well as a window into their rural, midwestern
lives and their roots as athletes, students, and friends." -- Shane Butterfield, Michigan Historical Review
Nathan Schreiner was far more distinguished off the field, a reality brought to life in the must-read bookThird Down and a
War to Go by Terry Frei."
-- Andy Baggot, Wisconsin State Journal
Third Down and a War to Go:
The All-American 1942 Wisconsin
Badgers was a 2004 hardback
"Terry Frei has captured the spirit of a different time in this country, a time of
faith in school and in country, a time of intense loyalty to teammate and fellow soldier. Third Down and a War
to Go tells the story of one University of Wisconsin football team during World War II. But to limit the
tale to that is like saying Angela's Ashes is about Ireland. This book brings to life, in shades of black
and blue and blood red, the idea that certain things are worth fighting for."
--Rick Morrissey, Chicago Tribune
“Tirelessly researched and relentlessly touching. The true allegory of football and war, minus
Greenberg, New York Post
"Terry Frei set out to learn more about his father. He wound up bringing to life a team, a cause
and an era. Likewise, all that the young men of the 1942 Wisconsin Badgers set out to be was college students and football
players. But circumstances called most of them to do something greater: Save the world. Impressively researched and reported
and powerfully written, Third Down and a War To Go will put you in
the huddle, in the front lines and in a state of profound gratitude -- not only to the Badgers and the hundreds of thousands
of men like them, but to Terry Frei.”
--Neal Rubin, Detroit News and
author of Gil Thorp
"...during World War II, as this book movingly
reminds us, there was little separation between war and football. Most of the young men who played at Camp Randall during the fall of 1942 were headed for
the service within a year, graduating seniors and underclassmen alike. All season long they knew what was coming, as did
their coach, Harry Stuhldreher, one of the famed Four Horsemen of Notre Dame.
"Soon enough his players were in the Marines, Navy, and Army
and fighting in all theaters of the world war. All of them were
doing only what they were expected to do, what they believed they had to do, not thinking
of themselves as especially brave and certainly not heroic. Yet it is impossible to read this book and not be awed by their actions.
"At the center of the story are the Touchdown
Twins, Dave Schreiner and Mark (Had) Hoskins, unforgettable middle-American archetypes. They were childhood pals from Lancaster, a small town of 2,600 in
southwestern Wisconsin, who lived out the dream of playing and starring together on the topflight Big Ten team up in Madison,
culminating with the 1942 season. The interwoven stories of
Had and Dave evoke hope and heartbreak.
was among a squadron of Wisconsin players
who became pilots (including Terry Frei’s dad, Jerry Frei, a backup guard). It was while flying a B-17 mission in Europe three weeks after D-Day in June 1944 that Had was shot down in Hungary near the German border.
"Schreiner joined the Marines and ended up leading a company into battle on Okinawa along with his Wisconsin teammate
Bob Baumann. Among the many striking moments in Frei’s
narrative, I will never forget
the scene of Schreiner sprinting
out of a trap staged on the island by the Japanese
and looking down at a corpse as he sped to safety. 'That looked like Bob,' he said, his eyes misting as he kept running. The account of
own final hours and how he died represents Frei’s deepest reporting and brought me to tears. It is impossible not to love Dave Schreiner,
who was the best of the 1942 Badgers, better than the more famous
Crazylegs, but more than that the best of humanity. His death
was front page news in the Wisconsin newspapers that June of 1945, and it hurts still sixty-one years later.
"I’ve already mapped out one of the first trips I intend to make when I get back to Wisconsin. I’m going to drive the highways winding through the beautiful rolling hills southwest of Madison to pay my respects to Had Hoskins and Dave Schreiner, the Touchdown Twins, who are buried at Lancaster’s Hillside Cemetery,
side by side."
-- From the foreword by David Maraniss
"While Schreiner's is among the most compelling, the
stories of these young men and their efforts and the battlefield recall a different era. . . These Badgers did their job as
teammates on the gridiron, and they headed off together to fight the Germans and Japanese, united in their purpose and with
a grateful nation behind them."
Angus, editor, Janesville Gazette, son of team manager Robert Angus
"Great job. So good that I was
brought to tears. So good that I almost need to visit the cemetery in Lancaster, Wis., and say 'thanks' to Dave Schreiner
and Mark Hoskins." --Randy Jesick, journalism professor, Indiana University of Pennsylvania
"The drama, heroism and pathos of this book would make a great movie that would star two Grant County
men -- Lancaster's Dave Schreiner and Mark Hoskins."
--Jon Angeli, Grant County Herald-Independent
"This is a story of the highest degree, one
that will leave the reader at various times laughing, mournful, amazed, and inspired. Third Down And A War To Go is
much more than just a football story. It is much more than just a war story. It is a story about us."
--Doug Warren, Badgernation.com
Sophomore Elroy "Crazylegs"
Hirsch follows the blocking of junior
Pat Harder against Ohio State. Before the season, which
would turn out to be Hirsch's only one at Wisconsin, famous Madison columnist "Roundy" Coughlin advised that
every Badger fan should "buy a ticket and hold onto your seat. We haven't had a runner like that since you used to wear stiff hats and button shoes going to class."
On the first day of '42 fall practice: sophomore
halfback Elroy Hirsch (40), senior tackle Bob
Baumann (74), senior end Dave Schreiner (80).
After the big victory over Ohio State,
coach Harry Stuhldreher, at center,
is joined by Mark Hoskins, Dave
Schreiner, Pat Harder and Elroy
The "Crazylegs" game came against Great Lakes,
with 1941 Hesiman Trophy
winner Bruce Smith and
former Detroit Lion Steve Belichick.